Siesta Key, Florida Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Big Water Fish Market $$ 766 reviews Seafood Markets, Seafood (941) 554-8101 6641 Midnight Pass RdSiesta Key, FL 34242 The Cottage $$ 1003 reviews New American, Peruvian, Tapas/Small Plates (941) 312-9300 153 Avenida MessinaSarasota, FL 34242 Island House Tap & Grill $$ 585 reviews Beer Bar, Seafood, Burgers (941) 487-8116 5110 Ocean BlvdSiesta Key, FL 34242 Spearfish Grille $$ 564 reviews Seafood (941) 349-1971 1265 Old Stickney Point RdSarasota, FL 34242 Summer House Steak & Seafood $ 529 reviews Seafood, Steakhouses (941) 260-2675 149 Avenida MessinaSiesta Key, FL 34242 Claytons Siesta Grille $$ 688 reviews New American, Seafood (941) 349-2800 1256 Old Stickney Point RdSarasota, FL 34242 Florence and the Spice Boys $$ 135 reviews Mediterranean, Middle Eastern (941) 923-9920 4990 South Tamiami TrlSarasota, FL 34231 Siesta Key Oyster Bar $$ 1670 reviews Seafood, Sports Bars, Music Venues (941) 346-5443 5238 Ocean BlvdSarasota, FL 34242 Toasted Mango Cafe $$ 351 reviews Cafes, Breakfast & Brunch, Diners (941) 552-6485 6621 Midnight Pass RdSarasota, FL 34242 Sun Garden Cafe $$ 803 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Cafes, American (941) 346-7170 210 Avenida MaderaSarasota, FL 34242 My Village Pub $$ 206 reviews New American, Pubs, Sports Bars (941) 777-6787 5200 Ocean BlvdSiesta Key, FL 34242 Screaming Goat Taqueria $ 586 reviews Latin American, Caterers (941) 210-3992 6566 Gateway AveSarasota, FL 34231 Siesta Sun Deck $ 18 reviews Sandwiches, Breakfast & Brunch, Hot Dogs (941) 807-6830 948 Beach RdSiesta Key, FL 34242 Anna's Deli Siesta Key $ 145 reviews Delis, Sandwiches (941) 349-4888 6535 Midnight Pass RdSarasota, FL 34242 Casa Masa $ 88 reviews Mexican (941) 922-8226 2773 Bee Ridge RdSarasota, FL 34239 Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar $$ 773 reviews Seafood, Bars, Music Venues (941) 349-3885 1200 Old Stickney Point RdSarasota, FL 34242 Bonjour French Cafe $$ 437 reviews French, Creperies, Breakfast & Brunch (941) 346-0600 5214 Ocean BlvdSiesta Key, FL 34242 Another Broken Egg Cafe $$ 555 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Cafes, American (941) 552-8320 140 Avenida MessinaSiesta Key, FL 34242 Miguel's $$ 209 reviews French, Desserts, Salad (941) 349-4024 6631 Midnight Pass RdSarasota, FL 34242 Capo Pazzo $$ 119 reviews Pizza, Salad, Bars (941) 487-8677 2053 Reynolds StSarasota, FL 34231 Boatyard Waterfront Bar and Grill $$ 382 reviews American, Seafood, Sports Bars (941) 921-6200 1500 Stickney Point RdSarasota, FL 34231 Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key $$ 236 reviews Seafood, Bars, American (941) 312-2422 1250 Stickney Point RdSarasota, FL 34242 Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill $$ 493 reviews Seafood, Seafood Markets (941) 413-7133 7119 S Tamiami TrlSarasota, FL 34231 The Breakfast Company $$ 89 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Bakeries, New American (941) 706-4225 4832 S Tamiami TrlSarasota, FL 34231 Gilligan's Island Bar & Grill $$ 419 reviews American, Music Venues, Tiki Bars (941) 346-8122 5253 Ocean BlvdSiesta Key, FL 34242